| Requirement | Verdict | Evidence |
|---|---|---|
| full_factorial Exactly four cells A-D are present and cover Renters x Surface-space saving, Renters x Lighting control, Makers x Surface-space saving, and Makers x Lighting control exactly once. | ✓ | Cells A-D cover Renters/Surface, Renters/Lighting, Makers/Surface, Makers/Lighting exactly once. |
| cell_fields Every cell labels Audience, Appeal, Headline, Primary text, Visual direction, CTA, and Creative rationale. | ✓ | Each cell (A-D) lists Audience, Appeal, Headline, Primary text, Visual direction, CTA, and Creative rationale. |
| budget_and_duration The plan reserves a maximum of $4,800 as a $1,200 cap per cell over 14 days; it does not promise that a stopped cell will spend its full cap. | ✓ | Execution rules state '$4,800 reserved' and 'Exactly $1,200 cap per cell' over 14 days, with the stop rule clarifying unused budget from a stopped cell remains unspent rather than guaranteeing full spend. |
| execution_rules_section A labeled Execution rules section is present. | ✓ | A section titled '## Execution rules' is present. |
| hypotheses_section A separate labeled Preregistered hypotheses section is present. | ✓ | A separate section titled '## Preregistered hypotheses' is present. |
| approved_cta All four CTA fields are exactly 'Explore the Arc Clip Lamp'. | ✓ | All four cells list CTA as 'Explore the Arc Clip Lamp' verbatim. |
| grounded_copy All copy and visuals use only supplied Arc Clip Lamp facts and avoid invented customers, results, proof, scarcity, offers, or capabilities. | ✓ | Copy uses only supplied facts (2.25-inch clamp, eight-hour battery, $68 price, included items) with no invented reviews, results, or scarcity. |
| cells_isolate_factors Product identity, offer, copy/visual format, placement, run dates, and measurement rules stay constant; cells vary only the assigned audience language and the assigned appeal's supported message and visual. | ✓ | Execution rules explicitly hold product identity, offer, format/placement, run dates, and measurement rules constant while only audience language and appeal-specific message/visual vary across cells. |
| factorial_hypotheses Exactly three directional landing-page-view-rate hypotheses are preregistered: one audience main effect, one appeal main effect, and one audience-by-appeal interaction; each names its comparison without changing an extra factor. | ✓ | Three directional hypotheses are given: Makers vs Renters (audience main effect), Surface-space saving vs Lighting control (appeal main effect), and a Makers×Lighting-control interaction, each comparing LPVR without altering an extra factor. |
| kpi_and_guardrail Landing-page-view rate is correctly defined as landing-page views / link clicks and cost per AddToCart is the guardrail. | ✓ | LPVR is defined as Landing-Page Views / Link Clicks and Cost per AddToCart is named as the guardrail metric. |
| stop_rule_exact The stop rule is exactly $300 spend with zero AddToCart for an individual cell; unused budget is not reallocated and any triggered stop makes the final result inconclusive. | ✓ | Rule states $300 spend with zero AddToCart triggers a stop, unused budget cannot be reallocated, and any stop makes the result inconclusive. |
| win_rule_exact A winner requires at least 15% relative landing-page-view-rate lift versus the click-weighted pooled rate of the other three cells (their total landing-page views / total link clicks) and at least 200 link clicks in every cell. | ✓ | Win rule requires ≥15% relative lift vs click-weighted pooled rate of the other three cells and ≥200 link clicks in every cell. |
| inconclusive_rule The plan explicitly declares the result inconclusive when the full win rule is not met and does not pick a winner from directional data alone. | ✓ | Inconclusive rule explicitly lists stop, insufficient clicks, or failure to meet the 15% lift as conditions for declaring the test inconclusive rather than picking a winner from directional data. |